Cast List
(alphabetically)
| Amir | Amerian | Newsboys | |
| Patti | Appel | Tessie Tura | |
| Millie | Boyce | Louise/GYPSY | |
| Bethany | Bryson | Specialty Act | |
| Valerie | Bubb | Miss Cratchett | |
| Corinne | Burkert | Torreadorables | |
| Michael | Calmis | Newsboys | |
| Forrest | Cronin | Tulsa | |
| Sam | Goity | Newsboys | |
| Zachary | Golan-Strieb | Newsboys | |
| Taryn | Issel | Torreadorables | |
| Daniel | Kapler | Herbie | |
| Stewart | Kramer | George/Pastey/Phil | |
| Annie | Larson | Electra | |
| Thomas | Leone | Pop/Cigar | |
| Annmarie | Martin ** | Mama Rose | |
| Kevin | McAweeney | Newsboys | |
| Madeline (Maddy) | McNamara | Torreadorables | |
| Alison | Meacham | Specialty Act | |
| Nicolette | Norgaard | Baby Louise | |
| Peter | O'Shea | Newsboys | |
| Maxwell | Pereira | Newsboys | |
| Cheryl | Ringman | Mazzeppa | |
| Alex | Rubin | Newsboys | |
| Rachel | Share-Sapolsky | Baby June | |
| J. Scott | Stewart | Bourgeron-Cochrone/Mr. Goldstone | |
| Isabella | van Etten | Specialty Act | |
| Aaron | van Etten | Uncle Jacko/Weber | |
| Zack | Weiss | Newsboys | |
| Lisa Marie | Woods | Torreadorables |
**Member of AEA